Home » Forums » Photo feedback » too soft or too sharp ?
Jean-Charles Hubert Member Joined in November 2014 Posts: 7 |
Posted 18 January 2015 - 05:49 CET |
Hi, your opinion please first picture was rejected as front being soft and as feared, second picture was rejected as over-sharpened Attached photos: |
Gerard van Oostrom Member Joined in December 2012 Posts: 80 |
Posted 19 January 2015 - 18:32 CET |
Jean-Charles, according to my troubled eyes both are OK, but why don't you appeal? |
mitchel kuppens Member Joined in July 2013 Posts: 13 |
Posted 19 January 2015 - 19:06 CET |
There are right Jean-Charles, try Angelo's tutorials they will help you. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbTttiHN0DmwSvPw9VUTSrg |
Jean-Charles Hubert Member Joined in November 2014 Posts: 7 |
Posted 19 January 2015 - 22:32 CET |
thanks, i would appeal but just by saying: ''but i think it,s not oversharpened" and then what ? the first time, picture was rejected because the blacks (engine) where blacked out. I fixed the problem , re-uploaded then as feared, another issue arose: front was soft ! SO fixed it wiht a slight high pass, and some careful layer "painting" and then it's considered too oversharpened. I've watched the tutorials, both Angleo,s and Andre's and i've learned a lot and now apply that to my editing routine. Plus both andre and Angelo give great advice with the motives with rejections. The frustration is the feeling that one is left guessing to what are the exact "parameters", if any exist, for rejection or acceptance, specially in regards to softness or over spharpening.
but life goes on, i still challenge myself to produce amazing spotting pictures that transpire my passion for aviation and my work is admired among a great number of my peers.
|
Jose I. Soria Full member Joined in April 2014 Posts: 39 |
Posted 19 January 2015 - 22:35 CET |
Hello Jean Charles! Nice to see you here... ;) In my opinion the second shot is oversharpened, the first one looks fine to me. I would try to appeal, and if that doesn't work, maybe try resizing to 1200px?
|
reus_747 Full member Joined in November 2012 Posts: 5 |
Posted 20 January 2015 - 05:36 CET |
Hi.
In my opinion, the second image is oversharpened, especially the logo is jagged. |
crav8or Member Joined in November 2013 Posts: 19 |
Posted 20 January 2015 - 17:27 CET |
For me the first one is great. No need for the second one.
I would appeal that one. I have one in appeal that has 3 days waiting.
AP, is the appealed pictures taking long now?? |
Log in to post in the forum.