Image Feedback... "not fit for an Aviation website".

Hello guys..

Well, I normally accept what the screeners say on a rejected image; In this case I accept what they put on my image but, got me thinking about it, thats why I'm making this topic.

This image was rejected because "The image doesn't fit for an aviation website due to the aircraft trail isn't too prominent on the photo"... I agree, the trail isn't too prominent, and on my "defense" it's really hard to make it prominent when you have that kind of light, anyway, I think it's ok the rejection, anyway I appeal the decision because I like the photo, but nothing more.

Because of this rejection, I want to ask: What's the line when a picture doesn't fit anymore with an aviation website?.. I mean, obviously there must be an aircraft in the photo! but, well you understand I think. Here's the image:

I want to use this to the future as I, of course, take all the feedbacks and the comments from the screeners very seriously to grow up as a photographer (at least in aviation photography) and make sure that the next time I'll be uploading better pictures!.. I'm really new on all of this, I don't even have a year with my camera, so...

Thanks to all of you guys! Greetings.

Diego.

(Full and unedited comment from First Screener)

Second opinion. Diego, Fantastic image. Fantastic light and color. But to be honest I think it does not fit for an aviation website as the A320 trail isn't too prominent in the photo.

(Full and unedited comment from Second Screener)

I agree with first screener. But feel free to appeal...

Have you appealed?

Hi Wallace

No, I don't, how can I appeal the picture?...

Anyway, this was just for information purpose, and make sure that anybody new don't get his image rejected by the same reason, and for me of course, to know where is the line and in the future be sure with what I'm uploading.

Diego.

You can appeal the photo by going to the "My photo section", then click "discussion with editor" and then select appeal photo in the top right of the screen and give a reason. Thanks.

Jeffrey.

Hi Jeffrey...

I try it but I can not access that section, when I click on the "Discussion with Editor" link, it sends me to an error page, I don't know if there's another way, or what can I do in this case... Thanks!

Diego.

Ridiculous rejection.

What about mine 3rd photo here then? Aircraft + Star trails?

http://www.airplane-pictures.net/photo/199630/gol-transportes-areos-boeing-737-800/

Shame nice image!!!!.................................cant see why it was rejected, looks as good as any other night trail shot on here

This post has been edited by Darryl Morrell on 7th August 2012 - 22:57

I decided to upload the image again because I can not reach to the appeal section, I don't know why, it seems that it's some kind of an error or something.

I hope this time get lucky with the screeners, and whatever they said, I accept it.

Darryl, thanks for the words!

Greetings!

Diego.

Hi Diego, I checked the photo appeal tool and it seems to work on my PC. If you are still experiencing the problems with your other photos drop me an e-mail to Team@Airplane-Pictures.net.

Thank you Martin.

I think is my PC or my navigator, I use Google Chrome, but I really don't know... anyway, thanks!

Diego.

I use Google Chrome too and everything is alright...

I think it is incredible, Diego.