Feedback please.

Forums home | Start new topic | Jump to the last reply

nickygrun
Member
Joined in December 2016
Posts: 4

Posted 4 March 2017 - 16:20 CET

Would these be accepted? thanks

Attached photos:

Tim Meyer

Member
Joined in December 2015
Posts: 20

Posted 4 March 2017 - 17:04 CET

Hello :)

IMHO the house and the tree in the first picture are distracting.

The second is a normal skyshot that is likely to be rejected. Please read the skyshot guidance :)

The third is OKAY tbh, but I would let the sky pop out a bit more. But all in all this could be accepted.

And the fourth is too dark and way too overprocessed in my opinion.

Have a nice day ;)

Javi Sanchez

Full member
Joined in June 2012
Posts: 45

Posted 4 March 2017 - 17:43 CET

I recommend you check this guidance.

http://www.airplane-pictures.net/sky-shots.php

If you have any question, feel free to ask!

Cheers!

Ricardo Hebmüller

Full member
Joined in August 2014
Posts: 89

Posted 4 March 2017 - 17:46 CET

Hello

for the first picture the house and the tree contribute to make a good composition, I like it.

For the other pictures I agree with Tim Meyer's oppinion, adding a note in the Etihad A380 to crop closer to the nose or extending the picture in the tail part.

Emirates A380 is also soft and I believe it won't be accepetd by the skyshot rules.

Best regards!

nickygrun Member Joined in December 2016 Posts: 4	Posted 4 March 2017 - 17:57 CET
	Thanks everybody for your feedback!

Vali Muresan Member Joined in January 2016 Posts: 20	Posted 7 March 2017 - 10:33 CET
	Etihad is oversharp, the rest are blurry/soft (you might have some problems with lens focus). Emirates is mostly out of focus and has a lot of dust spots around. Qatar is dark and the sky is noisy, sharpness is okish. The best of all is the BA one but in my opinion, all four will get rejected for various reasons

Jump to the top